Rural residential (RRES) sales used for the residential ECF Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Sale Price Instr. Terms of Sale Adj. Sale $ Cur. Asmnt. Asd/Adj. Sale Cur. Appraisal Land + Yard Bldg. Residual Cost Man. $ E.C.F. Floor Area $/Sq.Ft. ECF Area Dev. by Mean (%) Building Style Land Value Land Table Property Class 110-012-300-070-00 3620 N STARK RD 11/22/23 $225,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $225,000 $82,300 36.58 $164,666 $89,475 $135,525 $77,918 1.739 952 $142.36 RRES 48.9253 RANCH $78,583 Rural Residential 401 110-013-300-059-00 3196 N STARK RD 12/15/23 $836,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $836,000 $361,700 43.27 $723,327 $117,683 $718,317 $627,610 1.145 3,082 $233.07 RRES 10.5546 RAISED RANCH $101,876 Rural Residential 401 110-015-300-170-00 636 E GOLDEN POND RD 04/07/23 $155,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $155,000 $81,300 52.45 $162,551 $30,782 $124,218 $136,548 0.910 1,120 $110.91 RRES 34.0372 RANCH $24,510 Rural Residential 401 110-016-200-220-00 3302 N BRINK DR 05/21/24 $409,100 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $409,100 $191,800 46.88 $383,524 $69,552 $339,548 $335,799 1.011 1,970 $172.36 brink 23.8908 RANCH $57,696 Rural Residential 401 110-016-300-210-00 3100 N ANTIQUE CT 04/14/23 $745,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $745,000 $254,600 34.17 $509,185 $225,688 $519,312 $293,779 1.768 2,688 $193.20 RRES 51.7622 2 STORY $80,000 Rural Residential 401 110-021-200-240-00 248 E BOULIS DR 07/28/23 $25,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $25,000 $20,200 80.80 $40,472 $13,666 $11,334 $37,380 0.303 1,632 $6.94 RRES 94.6864 RANCH $12,616 Rural Residential 401 110-023-400-012-00 1345 E MONROE RD 10/31/23 $350,000 MLC 33-TO BE DETERMINED $350,000 $107,400 30.69 $214,808 $50,554 $299,446 $195,540 1.531 5,250 $57.04 RRES 28.1303 RANCH $29,880 Rural Residential 401 110-025-300-500-00 1717 E LETTS RD 05/23/23 $401,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $401,000 $157,200 39.20 $314,399 $34,060 $366,940 $290,507 1.263 2,004 $183.10 RRES 1.3031 RANCH $34,060 Rural Residential 401 110-025-400-165-00 2117 N DUBLIN RD 07/09/24 $238,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $238,000 $112,400 47.23 $224,718 $43,925 $194,075 $171,530 1.131 2,000 $97.04 RRES 11.8640 RANCH $23,400 Rural Residential 401 110-026-100-300-00 2297 N STARK RD 09/08/23 $327,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $327,000 $138,300 42.29 $276,640 $26,112 $300,888 $259,615 1.159 1,876 $160.39 RRES 9.1093 RANCH $26,112 Rural Residential 401 110-027-100-521-00 2314 N HOPE RD 12/12/23 $135,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $135,000 $59,600 44.15 $119,150 $33,172 $101,828 $89,096 1.143 1,162 $87.63 RRES 10.7175 RANCH $33,172 Rural Residential 401 110-027-200-009-00 588 E MONROE RD 04/28/23 $417,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $417,000 $147,000 35.25 $294,077 $69,608 $347,392 $232,610 1.493 2,520 $137.85 RRES 24.3378 1-1/2 STORY $57,582 Rural Residential 401 110-027-200-014-00 544 E MONROE RD 10/26/23 $640,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $640,000 $249,000 38.91 $497,964 $72,776 $567,224 $440,609 1.287 2,362 $240.15 RRES 3.7290 RAISED RANCH $57,582 Rural Residential 401 110-027-300-057-00 519 E PRICE RD 02/21/25 $525,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $525,000 $231,900 44.17 $463,820 $50,865 $474,135 $359,404 1.319 2,611 $181.59 RRES 6.9154 RANCH $50,865 Rural Residential 401 110-027-300-061-00 2022 N FIVE MILE RD 05/24/24 $319,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $319,000 $202,600 63.51 $405,259 $38,934 $280,066 $347,557 0.806 2,114 $132.48 RRES 44.4259 RANCH $30,164 Rural Residential 401 110-027-300-130-00 578 E PRICE RD 05/31/23 $290,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $290,000 $126,200 43.52 $252,432 $37,049 $252,951 $223,195 1.133 2,488 $101.67 RRES 11.6753 1-1/2 STORY $30,948 Rural Residential 401 110-027-400-206-00 2242 N HOPE RD 10/25/23 $405,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $405,000 $167,300 41.31 $334,628 $176,831 $228,169 $163,520 1.395 1,155 $197.55 RRES 14.5284 RANCH $98,504 Rural Residential 401 110-027-400-251-00 2196 N HOPE RD 08/11/23 $170,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $170,000 $78,800 46.35 $157,656 $43,621 $126,379 $118,171 1.069 1,032 $122.46 RRES 18.0614 RANCH $30,228 Rural Residential 401 110-027-400-308-00 865 E PRICE RD 05/02/24 $257,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $257,000 $106,400 41.40 $212,822 $32,612 $224,388 $170,977 1.312 1,772 $126.63 RRES 6.2313 RANCH $32,612 Rural Residential 401 110-027-400-512-00 898 E PRICE RD 04/14/23 $185,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $185,000 $100,500 54.32 $201,075 $49,359 $135,641 $157,219 0.863 1,120 $121.11 RRES 38.7319 RANCH $49,359 Rural Residential 401 110-027-400-760-00 850 E PRICE RD 07/14/23 $155,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $155,000 $56,500 36.45 $112,922 $16,752 $138,248 $99,658 1.387 988 $139.93 RRES 13.7151 RANCH $16,752 Rural Residential 401 110-027-400-780-00 765 E PRICE RD 01/22/24 $45,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $45,000 $30,600 68.00 $61,180 $17,160 $27,840 $41,765 0.667 780 $35.69 RRES 58.3481 RANCH $17,160 Rural Residential 401 110-027-400-780-00 765 E PRICE RD 12/17/24 $119,500 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $119,500 $34,000 28.45 $68,046 $18,480 $101,020 $43,138 2.342 780 $129.51 RRES 109.1693 RANCH $18,480 Rural Residential 401 110-028-300-040-00 100 E PRICE RD 02/17/25 $350,000 LC 33-TO BE DETERMINED $350,000 $149,900 42.83 $299,885 $58,971 $291,029 $209,673 1.388 2,652 $109.74 RRES 13.7943 RANCH $49,790 Rural Residential 401 110-028-300-055-00 80 E PRICE RD 04/23/24 $166,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $166,000 $81,400 49.04 $162,761 $27,440 $138,560 $128,388 1.079 1,260 $109.97 RRES 17.0844 RANCH $27,440 Rural Residential 401 110-033-100-300-00 275 E SAGINAW RD 04/30/24 $165,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $165,000 $71,400 43.27 $142,785 $26,326 $138,674 $110,492 1.255 1,248 $111.12 RRES 0.4982 RANCH $15,496 Rural Residential 401 110-033-100-510-00 456 E SAGINAW RD 01/04/24 $113,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $113,000 $50,300 44.51 $100,553 $12,142 $100,858 $83,881 1.202 1,045 $96.51 RRES 4.7685 RANCH $12,142 Rural Residential 401 110-034-100-180-00 838 E RED KEG CT 02/16/24 $151,500 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $151,500 $69,100 45.61 $138,125 $14,769 $136,731 $146,852 0.931 2,430 $56.27 RRES 31.8995 RANCH $12,090 Rural Residential 401 110-034-200-170-00 1951 N HOPE RD 04/05/24 $150,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $150,000 $56,500 37.67 $113,041 $8,658 $141,342 $99,035 1.427 1,496 $94.48 RRES 17.7118 RANCH $8,658 Rural Residential 401 110-034-200-420-00 581 E SANFORD RD 08/14/24 $125,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $125,000 $38,400 30.72 $76,845 $15,964 $109,036 $57,762 1.888 864 $126.20 RRES 63.7609 RANCH $15,964 Rural Residential 401 110-034-200-620-00 1815 N BURRELL ST 03/14/25 $78,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $78,000 $44,000 56.41 $87,921 $9,940 $68,060 $67,869 1.003 748 $90.99 RRES 24.7252 RANCH $9,940 Rural Residential 401 110-035-200-245-00 1049 E SANFORD RD 06/26/23 $230,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $230,000 $87,400 38.00 $174,775 $24,072 $205,928 $156,169 1.319 1,492 $138.02 RRES 6.8551 RANCH $24,072 Rural Residential 401 110-036-100-600-00 1799 N DUBLIN RD 06/06/24 $529,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $529,000 $199,500 37.71 $399,034 $88,683 $440,317 $294,451 1.495 3,488 $126.24 RRES 24.5312 RAISED RANCH $59,610 Rural Residential 401 110-036-300-025-00 1708 N STARK RD 04/07/23 $205,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $205,000 $91,000 44.39 $182,088 $51,993 $153,007 $134,813 1.135 1,826 $83.79 RRES 11.5119 RANCH $32,376 Rural Residential 401 110-036-300-130-00 1682 N STARK RD 10/23/24 $159,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $159,000 $60,900 38.30 $121,831 $23,400 $135,600 $93,388 1.452 1,204 $112.62 RRES 20.1933 RANCH $23,400 Rural Residential 401 Totals: $9,795,100 $9,795,100 $4,097,400 $8,194,965 $8,074,026 $6,495,921 $124.76 0.7135
Rural residential sales statistics Sale. Ratio => 41.83 Std. Dev. => 10.56 E.C.F. => 1.243 Ave. E.C.F. => 1.250 Std. Deviation=> 0.36406198 Ave. Variance=> 26.0624 Coefficient of Var=> 20.84870645
ECF Used in database: 1.149 91.91% Adjust by: 5.00%
Residential ECF update Current ECF Updated ECF RES 1.149 1.206
Page 2
Residential subdivision and neighborhood sales Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Sale Price Instr. Terms of Sale Adj. Sale $ Cur. Asmnt. Asd/Adj. Sale Cur. Appraisal Land + Yard Bldg. Residual Cost Man. $ E.C.F. Floor Area $/Sq.Ft. ECF Area From DB Dev. by Mean (%) Building Style Land Value Land Table Property Class 110-016-200-220-00 3302 N BRINK DR 05/21/24 $409,100 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $409,100 $191,800 46.88 $383,524 $69,552 $339,548 $335,799 1.011 1,970 $172.36 brink 0.993 3.4593 RANCH $57,696 Rural Residential 401 110-024-200-070-00 1591 E BLACKWOOD CT 06/01/23 $636,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $636,000 $327,500 51.49 $655,084 $64,515 $571,485 $620,998 0.920 3,901 $146.50 775 1.068 12.5489 RANCH $64,515 Blackwood 401 110-490-500-040-00 2030 N FANTASY LN 06/07/23 $400,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $400,000 $148,900 37.23 $297,891 $61,425 $338,575 $267,798 1.264 1,680 $201.53 490 0.992 21.8532 RANCH $61,425 Dream Chaser 401 110-525-500-080-00 1994 N PINESBORO DR 10/11/24 $330,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $330,000 $158,700 48.09 $317,464 $63,857 $266,143 $268,084 0.993 1,983 $134.21 525 1.005 5.2997 RAISED RANCH $53,930 Foxcroft Subdivision 401 110-525-500-130-00 330 E CARMEL DR 07/01/24 $440,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $440,000 $223,900 50.89 $447,846 $50,759 $389,241 $419,754 0.927 3,016 $129.06 525 1.005 11.8450 2 STORY $50,759 Foxcroft Subdivision 401 110-540-500-020-00 2707 N HEYWARD CIR 06/24/24 $385,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $385,000 $151,000 39.22 $302,020 $59,349 $325,651 $255,712 1.274 2,076 $156.86 540 1.007 22.7747 2 STORY $59,349 Heyward Estates 401 110-580-000-002-00 201 E PRICE RD 10/01/24 $290,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $290,000 $111,700 38.52 $223,413 $50,929 $239,071 $212,157 1.127 1,622 $147.39 LE1-2 0.864 8.1098 RANCH $34,704 Lincoln Estates No. 1 401 110-580-000-005-00 155 E PRICE RD 06/28/24 $245,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $245,000 $113,800 46.45 $227,509 $38,165 $206,835 $232,895 0.888 1,612 $128.31 LE1-2 0.864 15.7656 RANCH $34,704 Lincoln Estates No. 1 401 110-750-000-085-00 1998 N GREENMEADOW CT 06/27/24 $300,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $300,000 $142,100 47.37 $284,178 $102,126 $197,874 $196,388 1.008 2,088 $94.77 750 0.985 3.8193 2 STORY $79,737 Sherwood Meadows No. 1 401 Totals: $3,435,100 $3,435,100 $1,569,400 $3,138,929 $2,874,423 $2,809,586 $145.67 0.976 2.2681
Subdivision sales statistics Sale. Ratio => 45.69 Std. Dev. => 5.40 E.C.F. => 1.023 Ave. E.C.F. => 1.046 Std. Deviation=> 0.144178503 Ave. Variance=> 11.7195 Coefficient of Var=> 11.20671633
ECF Used in database: 0.976 93.31% Adjust by: 7.00%
Adjusted ECF 1.044
Subdivision ECF updates ECF Area Current ECF Updated ECF antq Antique Estates 0.992 1.061 Sales 775 Blackwood 1.006 1.076 brink Brinks Antique Area 0.935 1.000 Sales 490 Dreamchasers 0.934 0.999 Sales 525 Foxcroft Subdivision 0.946 1.013 Sales 540 Heyward Estates 0.949 1.015 Sales LE1-2 Lincoln Est. 1-2 0.813 0.870 Sales LE3-4 Lincoln Est. 3-4 0.842 0.901 Sales 750 Sherwood Meadows #1 0.927 0.992 770 Stargazers Subdivision 1.024 1.095
Page 3
Averill area sales Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Sale Price Instr. Terms of Sale Adj. Sale $ Cur. Asmnt. Asd/Adj. Sale Cur. Appraisal Land + Yard Bldg. Residual Cost Man. $ E.C.F. Floor Area $/Sq.Ft. ECF Area From DB Dev. by Mean (%) Building Style Land Value Land Table Property Class 110-450-500-291-00 1852 N FRANCIS ST 05/15/24 $220,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $220,000 $103,400 47.00 $206,704 $12,122 $207,878 $183,568 1.132 1,338 $155.36 Avrl 1.165 0.0000 RANCH $12,122 Burrell's Plat of Averill 401 Totals: $220,000 $220,000 $103,400 $206,704 $207,878 $183,568 $155.36 1.165 0.0000
Averill area sales statistics Sale. Ratio => 47.00 Std. Dev. => #DIV/0! E.C.F. => 1.132 Ave. E.C.F. => 1.132 Std. Deviation=> #DIV/0! Ave. Variance=> 0.0000 Coefficient of Var=> 0
ECF Used in database: 1.165 102.83% Adjust by: 0.00%
Adjusted ECF 1.165
ECF updates for Averill and other areas ECF Area Current ECF Updated ECF Sales avrl Averill Area 1.165 1.165 500 Golden Pond 1.235 1.235 985 Old Oak Trails 0.916 0.916 700 Pineridge 1.115 1.115
Page 4
AG Agricultural sales Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Sale Price Instr. Terms of Sale Adj. Sale $ Asd. when Sold Asd/Adj. Sale Cur. Appraisal Land + Yard Bldg. Residual Cost Man. $ E.C.F. Floor Area $/Sq.Ft. ECF Area Dev. by Mean (%) Building Style Land Value Other Parcels in Sale Property Class 090-027-200-270-00 3636 E MONROE RD 01/12/24 $180,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $180,000 $102,200 56.78 $223,328 $49,522 $130,478 $180,110 0.724 2,409 $54.16 4100 21.1378 1 STY $49,522 401 100-011-300-020-00 186 N EIGHT MILE RD 10/11/23 $280,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $280,000 $159,100 56.82 $354,948 $32,865 $247,135 $330,342 0.748 2,880 $85.81 4300 18.7694 2 STY $32,865 401 100-034-100-840-00 1602 S EIGHT MILE RD 07/28/23 $82,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $82,000 $43,700 53.29 $92,132 $47,585 $34,415 $45,689 0.753 720 $47.80 4300 18.2572 MOBILE $44,161 401 130-032-100-180-00 4899 N EASTMAN RD 11/19/24 $118,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $118,000 $68,800 58.31 $144,291 $23,800 $94,200 $123,581 0.762 1,782 $52.86 4300 17.3557 MANUFACTURED $23,800 401 110-036-300-025-00 1708 N STARK RD 04/07/23 $205,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $205,000 $92,200 44.98 $245,281 $44,612 $160,388 $207,947 0.771 1,827 $87.79 4100 16.4521 1 STY $38,750 401 110-025-400-165-00 2117 N DUBLIN RD 07/09/24 $238,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $238,000 $113,800 47.82 $286,849 $26,100 $211,900 $270,206 0.784 2,210 $95.88 4100 15.1597 1 STY $26,100 401 130-033-300-080-00 3187 E SHERRY LN 02/26/24 $275,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $275,000 $143,400 52.15 $329,075 $29,632 $245,368 $307,121 0.799 1,862 $131.78 4300 13.6884 1-3/4 STY $28,704 401 030-005-100-350-00 5180 W HINES RD 12/11/23 $75,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $75,000 $34,300 45.73 $82,942 $31,500 $43,500 $52,761 0.824 898 $48.44 4300 11.1341 1 STY $31,500 401 060-011-100-060-00 2088 S SMITHS CROSSING RD 07/19/23 $224,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $224,000 $68,100 30.40 $255,631 $38,200 $185,800 $225,317 0.825 1,824 $101.86 4100 11.1198 1 STY $38,200 401 100-022-400-011-00 1230 W CHIPPEWA RIVER RD 10/20/23 $206,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $206,000 $73,400 35.63 $236,110 $29,627 $176,373 $211,777 0.833 1,708 $103.26 4300 10.2991 1 STY $28,020 401 110-027-400-512-00 898 E PRICE RD 04/14/23 $185,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $185,000 $96,600 52.22 $205,666 $51,384 $133,616 $159,878 0.836 1,120 $119.30 4100 10.0075 1 STY $51,384 401 160-013-100-055-00 3181 W SHEARER RD 01/05/24 $154,900 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $154,900 $37,100 23.95 $174,581 $30,300 $124,600 $147,981 0.842 1,200 $103.83 4300 9.3810 1 STY $30,300 401 030-005-100-150-00 5280 W HINES RD 09/26/24 $190,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $190,000 $95,500 50.26 $212,704 $31,500 $158,500 $185,850 0.853 1,698 $93.35 4300 8.2976 1 STY $31,500 401 160-021-100-045-00 4647 W BAKER RD 05/25/23 $477,500 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $477,500 $207,300 43.41 $524,430 $113,456 $364,044 $421,512 0.864 2,804 $129.83 4300 7.2151 1-1/2 STY $99,000 401 050-025-200-102-00 1582 E BAKER RD 04/27/23 $85,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $85,000 $40,700 47.88 $89,184 $51,866 $33,134 $38,080 0.870 1,056 $31.38 4400 6.5688 MOBILE $51,866 401 100-018-100-150-00 2613 W ISABELLA RD 02/07/25 $188,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $188,000 $67,400 35.85 $207,728 $21,800 $166,200 $190,695 0.872 1,585 $104.86 4300 6.4266 1 STY $21,800 401 130-002-200-070-00 7322 N SWEDE RD 08/16/23 $65,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $65,000 $32,800 50.46 $68,491 $34,789 $30,211 $34,566 0.874 1,144 $26.41 4300 6.1808 MOBILE $34,503 401 020-020-100-030-00 5175 W MCNALLY RD 11/25/24 $173,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $173,000 $88,400 51.10 $190,161 $21,800 $151,200 $172,678 0.876 1,456 $103.85 4300 6.0195 1 STY $21,800 401 160-032-100-360-00 5112 W STAR RD 04/16/24 $271,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $271,000 $146,400 54.02 $294,823 $51,480 $219,520 $249,530 0.880 1,260 $174.22 4300 5.6079 1-1/2 STY $50,325 401 100-035-200-321-00 1555 S EIGHT MILE RD 12/09/24 $414,500 WD 19-MULTI PARCEL ARM'S LENGTH $414,500 $222,900 53.78 $448,757 $76,787 $337,713 $381,508 0.885 1,726 $195.66 4300 5.0607 1 STY $60,550 100-035-200-277-00 401 020-006-200-010-00 5865 W BURNS RD 07/31/23 $106,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $106,000 $45,900 43.30 $114,258 $21,880 $84,120 $94,729 0.888 1,182 $71.17 4300 4.7808 2 STY $21,880 401 010-012-200-300-00 6260 N WATER RD 01/02/24 $175,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $175,000 $102,800 58.74 $189,193 $22,920 $152,080 $169,842 0.895 2,200 $69.13 4400 4.0391 1-3/4 STY $22,920 401 040-009-200-300-00 756 N MERIDIAN RD 04/29/24 $283,250 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $283,250 $80,500 28.42 $298,563 $54,817 $228,433 $252,587 0.904 1,466 $155.82 4100 3.1438 1 STY $49,452 401 060-002-400-195-00 1799 E RIVER RD 11/29/23 $239,900 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $239,900 $105,000 43.77 $251,588 $54,455 $185,445 $204,283 0.908 1,684 $110.12 4100 2.8028 1 STY $50,152 401 160-036-200-065-00 3477 W FIKE RD 02/02/24 $220,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $220,000 $90,000 40.91 $232,744 $31,819 $188,181 $206,077 0.913 1,372 $137.16 4300 2.2654 1 STY $31,819 401 030-031-200-110-00 1649 S COUNTY LINE RD 09/06/23 $265,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $265,000 $65,900 24.87 $280,659 $32,562 $232,438 $254,458 0.913 1,152 $201.77 4300 2.2352 1 STY $31,500 401 080-034-200-001-00 1371 W WACKERLY RD 06/14/23 $208,500 WD 19-MULTI PARCEL ARM'S LENGTH $208,500 $99,500 47.72 $197,037 $49,214 $159,286 $174,338 0.914 1,676 $95.04 4300 2.2150 1 STY $46,120 080-034-200-022-00 401 160-002-400-115-00 6589 N MAGRUDER RD 08/03/23 $176,400 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $176,400 $66,700 37.81 $185,806 $22,000 $154,400 $168,006 0.919 1,200 $128.67 4300 1.6799 1 STY $22,000 401 060-006-200-280-00 1758 S GREY RD 05/26/23 $261,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $261,000 $89,000 34.10 $271,382 $52,975 $208,025 $226,329 0.919 2,188 $95.08 4100 1.6685 BI-LEVEL $52,975 401 130-033-300-076-00 3133 E SHERRY LN 08/09/24 $283,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $283,000 $116,000 40.99 $297,151 $14,000 $269,000 $290,411 0.926 2,076 $129.58 4300 0.9541 1+STY $14,000 401 160-035-300-115-00 4202 N ALAMANDO RD 08/14/24 $209,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $209,000 $99,800 47.75 $218,039 $17,947 $191,053 $205,223 0.931 2,125 $89.91 4300 0.4858 1 STY $14,000 401 130-032-400-015-00 2863 E BOMBAY RD 08/08/23 $355,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $355,000 $140,000 39.44 $366,741 $41,382 $313,618 $333,702 0.940 1,664 $188.47 4300 0.4003 1 STY $41,382 401 110-016-200-220-00 3302 N BRINK DR 05/21/24 $409,100 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $409,100 $194,000 47.42 $416,522 $51,930 $357,170 $377,505 0.946 1,970 $181.30 4100 1.0320 1 STY $51,930 401 040-014-100-230-00 1346 E OLSON RD 10/26/23 $280,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $280,000 $82,400 29.43 $282,652 $48,033 $231,967 $242,656 0.956 1,142 $203.12 4100 2.0138 1-1/4 STY $38,200 401 040-004-300-210-00 1002 N MERIDIAN RD 01/23/24 $154,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $154,000 $70,700 45.91 $154,467 $58,989 $95,011 $98,941 0.960 1,036 $91.71 4100 2.4467 1 STY $52,533 401 010-003-400-200-00 1033 W LEVELY RD 05/16/24 $341,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $341,000 $164,400 48.21 $345,882 $44,000 $297,000 $308,043 0.964 1,585 $187.38 4400 2.8338 1 STY $44,000 401 010-031-200-105-00 2990 W GINGER DR 05/22/23 $376,900 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $376,900 $120,800 32.05 $382,384 $27,162 $349,738 $362,471 0.965 1,904 $183.69 4400 2.9057 1 STY $27,162 401 100-024-400-040-00 174 W MILLER RD 10/11/23 $195,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $195,000 $67,100 34.41 $196,570 $34,117 $160,883 $166,546 0.966 960 $167.59 4300 3.0184 1 STY $29,100 401 090-300-500-431-00 3969 N EHLERS RD 07/06/23 $451,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $451,000 $203,300 45.08 $453,057 $88,665 $362,335 $374,427 0.968 2,094 $173.03 4101 3.1893 2 STY $86,410 101 030-024-100-700-00 534 S CASTOR RD 07/21/23 $500,000 WD 19-MULTI PARCEL ARM'S LENGTH $500,000 $220,500 44.10 $455,404 $132,927 $367,073 $379,272 0.968 1,997 $183.81 4300 3.2021 1 STY $120,096 030-024-100-220-00, 030-024-100-470- 401 050-011-400-170-00 1263 E CURTIS RD 08/21/23 $365,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $365,000 $173,100 47.42 $368,976 $21,800 $343,200 $354,261 0.969 2,054 $167.09 4400 3.2963 2 STY $21,800 401 020-004-200-055-00 4947 W BURNS RD 02/14/25 $145,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $145,000 $62,900 43.38 $145,676 $30,688 $114,312 $117,748 0.971 1,070 $106.83 4300 3.5002 1 STY $28,608 401 100-013-300-005-00 267 S SEVEN MILE RD 07/13/23 $262,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $262,000 $99,500 37.98 $262,271 $69,570 $192,430 $197,642 0.974 3,360 $57.27 4300 3.7816 2 STY $65,650 401 040-035-300-271-00 1060 E STEWART RD 05/24/24 $240,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $240,000 $129,000 53.75 $237,984 $32,228 $207,772 $213,219 0.974 1,633 $127.23 4100 3.8642 BI-LEVEL $28,540 401 110-027-300-130-00 578 E PRICE RD 05/31/23 $290,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $290,000 $120,600 41.59 $284,705 $38,970 $251,030 $254,648 0.986 2,696 $93.11 4100 4.9980 1-1/2 STY $38,970 401 080-025-300-600-00 250 W WACKERLY RD 09/01/23 $180,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $180,000 $82,900 46.06 $178,005 $44,000 $136,000 $137,441 0.990 1,499 $90.73 4300 5.3702 1-3/4 STY $44,000 401 110-028-300-055-00 80 E PRICE RD 04/23/24 $166,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $166,000 $82,200 49.52 $160,851 $28,906 $137,094 $136,731 1.003 1,260 $108.80 4100 6.6845 1 STY $28,906 401 110-036-100-600-00 1799 N DUBLIN RD 06/06/24 $529,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $529,000 $202,100 38.20 $507,646 $55,191 $473,809 $467,911 1.013 3,774 $125.55 4100 7.6793 2 STY $52,780 401 110-025-300-500-00 1717 E LETTS RD 05/23/23 $401,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $401,000 $149,700 37.33 $366,240 $44,141 $356,859 $333,781 1.069 2,004 $178.07 4100 13.3327 1 STY $42,050 401 060-005-400-725-00 2933 E HILLSIDE DR 06/16/23 $339,400 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $339,400 $123,400 36.36 $310,336 $42,745 $296,655 $277,296 1.070 1,792 $165.54 4100 13.3999 1 STY $38,200 401 040-014-100-230-00 1346 E OLSON RD 01/30/25 $308,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $308,000 $140,500 45.62 $282,652 $48,033 $259,967 $242,656 1.071 1,142 $227.64 4100 13.5528 1-1/4 STY $38,200 401 050-003-400-000-00 7261 N MIDDLE RD 11/01/23 $325,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $325,000 $124,600 38.34 $307,901 $132,000 $193,000 $179,956 1.072 1,778 $108.55 4400 13.6671 1 STY $132,000 401 020-011-400-110-00 3110 N BUSH RD 06/09/23 $295,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $295,000 $105,400 35.73 $271,804 $40,611 $254,389 $237,121 1.073 1,388 $183.28 4300 13.7010 2 STY $40,611 401 110-027-100-521-00 2314 N HOPE RD 12/12/23 $135,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $135,000 $57,600 42.67 $125,680 $41,500 $93,500 $87,110 1.073 1,162 $80.46 4100 13.7542 1-3/4 STY $41,500 401 110-027-200-014-00 544 E MONROE RD 10/26/23 $640,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $640,000 $237,300 37.08 $579,184 $53,586 $586,414 $544,229 1.078 3,926 $149.37 4100 14.1700 2 STY $53,586 401 110-027-400-308-00 865 E PRICE RD 05/02/24 $257,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $257,000 $107,800 41.95 $226,376 $38,200 $218,800 $195,001 1.122 1,996 $109.62 4100 18.6232 1 STY $38,200 401 130-029-200-010-00 2692 E BAKER RD 11/17/23 $169,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $169,000 $59,400 35.15 $150,122 $27,343 $141,657 $125,927 1.125 1,344 $105.40 4300 18.9099 MANUFACTURED $22,000 401 110-027-200-009-00 588 E MONROE RD 04/28/23 $417,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $417,000 $140,900 33.79 $366,572 $62,921 $354,079 $314,664 1.125 2,520 $140.51 4100 18.9446 1-1/2 STY $53,586 401 081-025-100-085-00 75 W SAGINAW RD 12/20/24 $169,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $169,000 $84,100 49.76 $148,969 $19,000 $150,000 $133,302 1.125 1,221 $122.85 4300 18.9455 1 STY $19,000 401 050-036-400-090-00 4644 N HICKS RD 07/03/24 $278,000 MLC 03-ARM'S LENGTH $278,000 $104,900 37.73 $246,801 $46,450 $231,550 $205,324 1.128 2,418 $95.76 1400 19.1916 2 STY $46,450 101 Totals: $15,486,350 $15,486,350 $6,546,300 $15,785,962 $12,828,068 $13,582,940 $121.33 0.8612
Agricultural sales statistics Sale. Ratio => 42.27 Std. Dev. => 8.27 E.C.F. => 0.944 Ave. E.C.F. => 0.936 Std. Deviation=> 0.1045 Ave. Variance=> 8.3470 Coefficient of Var=> 8.919482601
Used in Database: 0.921
Adjusted 0.936
Page 5
Commercial Commercial sales Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Sale Price Instr. Terms of Sale Adj. Sale $ Cur. Asmnt. Asd/Adj. Sale Cur. Appraisal Land + Yard Bldg. Residual Cost Man. $ E.C.F. Floor Area $/Sq.Ft. ECF Area Dev. by Mean (%) Building Style Land Value Land Table Property Class 110-033-100-442-00 330 E SAGINAW RD 10/30/23 $249,000 MLC 03-ARM'S LENGTH $249,000 $136,400 54.78 $274,828 $28,072 $220,928 $288,266 0.766 4,873 $45.34 2100 13.9778 $28,072 2100 OCMR 201 120-029-100-885-00 2968 VENTURE DR 01/10/24 $500,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $500,000 $136,600 27.32 $338,382 $47,553 $452,447 $339,754 1.332 13,572 $33.34 2100 42.5511 $47,553 2100 OCMR 201 090-028-200-349-00 3003 E COMMERCIAL DR 12/18/23 $147,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $147,000 $50,900 34.63 $149,371 $62,370 $84,630 $104,569 0.809 3,584 $23.61 2200 9.6855 $61,254 2200 US-10/CITY INFL 201 030-016-200-410-00 4993 W ISABELLA RD 07/05/23 $475,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $475,000 $173,100 36.44 $393,665 $32,942 $442,058 $429,432 1.029 8,640 $51.16 2201 12.3221 $32,942 2203 STATE HWY/OUTER COUNTY 201 170-003-100-430-00 403 E WASHINGTON ST 04/19/23 $111,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $111,000 $41,000 36.94 $130,668 $8,160 $102,840 $158,689 0.648 2,800 $36.73 2300 25.8121 $8,160 2300 COLEMAN 201 170-006-200-170-00 115 N FOURTH ST 09/01/23 $150,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $150,000 $30,500 20.33 $129,664 $1,428 $148,572 $166,109 0.894 1,890 $78.61 2300 1.1755 $1,428 2300 COLEMAN 201 060-016-200-295-00 2711 S POSEYVILLE RD 08/25/23 $80,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $80,000 $27,800 34.75 $75,331 $11,580 $68,420 $79,194 0.864 3,850 $17.77 2400 4.2224 $11,580 2400 ACREAGE 201 Totals: $1,712,000 $1,712,000 $596,300 $1,491,909 $1,519,895 $1,566,012 $40.94 6.4371
Commercial sales statistics Sale. Ratio => 34.83 Std. Dev. => 9.02 E.C.F. => 0.971 Ave. E.C.F. => 0.906 Std. Deviation=> 0.13431073 Ave. Variance=> 10.4033 Coefficient of Var=> 11.48040131
Average ECF Used in database: 0.723 79.79% Adjust by: 24.50%
0.900
Commercial ECF updates Current ECF Updated ECF Commercial Property on Meridian 0.723 0.900 Com Sag-Wkrly Rd 0.723 0.900 Com S Stark - Airport Rd 0.723 0.900
Page 6
Industrial Industrial sales Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Sale Price Instr. Terms of Sale Adj. Sale $ Asd. when Sold Asd/Adj. Sale Cur. Appraisal Land + Yard Bldg. Residual Cost Man. $ E.C.F. Floor Area $/Sq.Ft. ECF Area Dev. by Mean (%) Building Style Use Code Land Value Other Parcels in Sale Property Class 110-033-100-442-00 330 E SAGINAW RD 10/30/23 $249,000 MLC 03-ARM'S LENGTH $249,000 $136,400 54.78 $274,828 $28,072 $220,928 $288,266 0.766 4,873 $45.34 2100 10.8857 MEDICAL $28,072 201 090-028-200-349-00 3003 E COMMERCIAL DR 12/18/23 $147,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $147,000 $50,900 34.63 $149,371 $62,370 $84,630 $104,569 0.809 3,584 $23.61 2200 6.5933 STORE RETAIL $61,254 201 030-016-200-410-00 4993 W ISABELLA RD 07/05/23 $475,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $475,000 $173,100 36.44 $393,665 $32,942 $442,058 $429,432 1.029 8,640 $51.16 2201 15.4142 STORE RETAIL $32,942 201 100-011-400-570-00 664 W ISABELLA RD 08/08/24 $200,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $200,000 $51,900 25.95 $177,777 $51,767 $148,233 $150,012 0.988 4,264 $34.76 2201 11.2882 STORE RETAIL $45,756 201 110-021-200-303-00 2860 N MERIDIAN RD 05/02/24 $100,000 LC 33-TO BE DETERMINED $100,000 $26,200 26.20 $74,179 $38,400 $61,600 $42,594 1.446 1,960 $31.43 2203 57.0952 GAR SERVICE $37,200 201 170-003-100-430-00 403 E WASHINGTON ST 04/19/23 $111,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $111,000 $41,000 36.94 $130,668 $8,160 $102,840 $158,689 0.648 2,800 $36.73 2300 22.7200 LAUNDROMAT $8,160 201 170-006-200-170-00 115 N FOURTH ST 09/01/23 $150,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $150,000 $30,500 20.33 $129,664 $1,428 $148,572 $166,109 0.894 1,890 $78.61 2300 1.9167 RESTAURANTS $1,428 201 060-016-200-295-00 2711 S POSEYVILLE RD 08/25/23 $80,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $80,000 $27,800 34.75 $75,331 $11,580 $68,420 $79,194 0.864 3,850 $17.77 2400 1.1303 GAR SERVICE $11,580 201 150-009-200-310-00 1989 W PINE RIVER RD 04/01/24 $1,150,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $1,150,000 $726,200 63.15 $1,317,896 $97,635 $1,052,365 $1,467,970 0.717 6,920 $152.08 2400 15.8375 1 STY MHP REC (UIP 13) $87,559 150-008-400-108-00 201 110-033-100-442-00 330 E SAGINAW RD 10/30/23 $249,000 MLC 03-ARM'S LENGTH $249,000 $136,400 54.78 $274,828 $28,072 $220,928 $288,266 0.766 4,873 $45.34 2100 10.8857 MEDICAL $28,072 201 030-016-200-410-00 4993 W ISABELLA RD 07/05/23 $475,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $475,000 $173,100 36.44 $393,665 $32,942 $442,058 $429,432 1.029 8,640 $51.16 2201 15.4142 STORE RETAIL $32,942 201 100-011-400-570-00 664 W ISABELLA RD 08/08/24 $200,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $200,000 $51,900 25.95 $177,777 $51,767 $148,233 $150,012 0.988 4,264 $34.76 2201 11.2882 STORE RETAIL $45,756 201 090-028-200-349-00 3003 E COMMERCIAL DR 12/18/23 $147,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $147,000 $50,900 34.63 $149,371 $62,370 $84,630 $104,569 0.809 3,584 $23.61 2200 6.5933 STORE RETAIL $61,254 201 170-003-100-430-00 403 E WASHINGTON ST 04/19/23 $111,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $111,000 $41,000 36.94 $130,668 $8,160 $102,840 $158,689 0.648 2,800 $36.73 2300 22.7200 LAUNDROMAT $8,160 201 170-006-200-170-00 115 N FOURTH ST 09/01/23 $150,000 WD 03-ARM'S LENGTH $150,000 $30,500 20.33 $129,664 $1,428 $148,572 $166,109 0.894 1,890 $78.61 2300 1.9167 RESTAURANTS $1,428 201 060-016-200-295-00 2711 S POSEYVILLE RD 08/25/23 $80,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $80,000 $27,800 34.75 $75,331 $11,580 $68,420 $79,194 0.864 3,850 $17.77 2400 1.1303 GAR SERVICE $11,580 201 150-009-200-310-00 1989 W PINE RIVER RD 04/01/24 $1,150,000 WD 33-TO BE DETERMINED $1,150,000 $726,200 63.15 $1,317,896 $97,635 $1,052,365 $1,467,970 0.717 6,920 $152.08 2400 15.8375 1 STY MHP REC (UIP 13) $87,559 150-008-400-108-00 201 Totals: $5,224,000 $5,224,000 $2,501,800 $5,372,579 $4,597,692 $5,731,076 $53.62 7.3020
Industrial sales statistics Sale. Ratio => 47.89 Std. Dev. => 20.08 E.C.F. => 0.802 Ave. E.C.F. => 0.875 Std. Deviation=> 0.103995794 Ave. Variance=> 8.4839 Coefficient of Var=> 9.692977805
Average ECF Used in database: 0.883 100.88% Adjust by: -1.50%
0.870
Industrial ECF update Current ECF Updated ECF Industrial Section 36 0.883 0.870